WITCHCRAFT - The Law Mind Legal Dictionary

WITCHCRAFTAuthored

The Law Mind • 1055 words

Definition

As a legal term, witchcraft refers to the statutory offense of alleged intercourse with evil spirits or the practice of sorcery and conjuration, as defined and punished under English penal legislation from the sixteenth through early eighteenth centuries. The term has no living operative meaning in modern law; it is purely a historical legal category. Under 33 Hen. VIII c. 8 and 1 Jac. I c. 12, witchcraft was a capital offense in England. Both statutes were repealed in 1736. The 1736 repeal did not rehabilitate the accused or eliminate the offense entirely — it replaced criminal prosecution for actual witchcraft with a lesser offense targeting those who pretended or claimed to practice witchcraft, sorcery, or related arts. Under 9 Geo. II c. 5 (later consolidated and amended by 5 Geo. IV c. 83, s. 4), persons pretending to use witchcraft or sorcery became punishable by imprisonment, not death.

Common Language

Modern common usage (Wiktionary): The practice of magic, sorcery, or the use of supernatural powers to influence events; black magic; also, colloquially, any seemingly magical or irresistible influence.

Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): The practices or art of witches; sorcery; enchantments; intercourse with evil spirits; also, any power more than natural or irresistible influence.

The gap between common and legal meaning here is structural rather than semantic. Common usage treats witchcraft as a description of a practice — real or metaphorical. The legal meaning was always statutory: witchcraft as a defined criminal offense whose content was determined by specific acts of Parliament, not by folk belief or theological definition. A researcher must resist importing the popular or literary sense into historical legal documents; when a legal source says "witchcraft," the operative question is always which statute was in force at the time.

Common Confusion

Two phases of English law are frequently conflated in secondary literature. The pre-1736 regime treated witchcraft as a serious felony punishable by death, premised on the assumption that actual intercourse with evil spirits had occurred. The post-1736 regime abolished that offense but created a new one targeting pretenders — those who falsely claimed occult powers, typically in the context of fraud. These are legally distinct offenses with different theories of harm, different elements, and different historical trajectories. Conflating them distorts both the history of capital punishment and the history of fraud law. The 1736 legislation marked a shift from theological criminality to secular consumer protection logic — punishing the deceiver, not the supposed practitioner.

Why It Matters in Research

Witchcraft is a term that appears in legal sources across a surprisingly long arc — from Tudor criminal statutes through nineteenth-century common law digests — and its meaning is not stable across that arc. Researchers working in pre-1736 English sources will encounter witchcraft as a capital felony with attendant procedural and evidentiary complications unique to that period. Researchers in post-1736 sources will find a transformed offense, one that sits closer to vagrancy law and fraud than to heresy or felony.

The colonial American dimension is a separate research track entirely. Colonial witchcraft prosecutions, most famously in Massachusetts in 1692, operated under local statute and common law adaptations, not directly under 1 Jac. I c. 12, and the legal framework varied by colony. Researchers should not assume that English statutory authority translated uniformly to the colonies.

The nineteenth-century dictionaries — including Blackstone's discussion, which Anderson's reproduces — treat witchcraft with a combination of historical distance and mild condescension ("a species of offense of which one knows not well what account to give"), reflecting the post-Enlightenment legal establishment's discomfort with the subject. This editorial tone can obscure the fact that prosecutions were legally serious and procedurally elaborate in their own time.

For Law Mind corpus researchers: witchcraft appears as a cross-reference point in discussions of felony classification, capital punishment history, the repeal of obsolete statutes, and — after 1736 — in the lineage of fraud and false pretenses law. The Witena-Gemote entry in Bouvier immediately follows the witchcraft entry and is unrelated; do not allow proximity in digest arrangement to suggest conceptual connection.

Historical Dictionary Support

The historical dictionaries converge on the core statutory framework but vary in depth and emphasis. Bouvier and both editions of Black's track directly to 4 Bl. Comm. 60-61 and the two principal statutes (33 Hen. VIII c. 8; 1 Jac. I c. 12), noting the capital penalty and the 1736 repeal. This is the standard digest account.

Rapalje & Lawrence provides the more useful post-repeal picture, citing both 9 Geo. II c. 5 and 5 Geo. IV c. 83, and noting the shift to imprisonment for pretenders. This is the operative framework for the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries and is underrepresented in the other sources. Rapalje also points to Broom & Hadley's Commentaries and Stephens' Commentaries as secondary authorities worth consulting for the transitional period.

Anderson's, drawing on Blackstone, offers the definitional content — "a woman (formerly, a man or a woman) supposed to be able to affect the happiness and destiny of other persons by the exercise of supernatural power acquired from intercourse with evil spirits" — which is valuable precisely because it shows how the legal definition tracked the folk and theological understanding of the offense rather than any empirically verifiable act. This definitional circularity is part of why the offense became legally untenable and was ultimately abolished as a capital crime.

What the historical dictionaries collectively miss is the American colonial dimension and any treatment of witchcraft prosecutions outside the English statutory framework. Researchers working on Scottish, continental European, or colonial American materials will find these sources of limited direct value.

Jurisdictional Note

English law is the primary legal framework in which witchcraft had formal statutory content. Scottish witchcraft law developed on a separate track and was not abolished until the same 1736 Act that repealed the English statutes. American colonial prosecutions operated under local authority and varied significantly by colony; no uniform American statutory framework for witchcraft ever existed at the federal level, and most colonial-era statutes lapsed or were repealed well before American independence.

WITCHCRAFTmain

Black's Law Dictionary • 1891

Under Sts. 33 Hen.

WITCHCRAFTmain

Rapalje & Lawrence • 1883

- Conjuration; sorcery. No prosecution shall for the future be carried on against any person for witchcraft, sorcery, enother with any such offense; but all persons pretending to use the same shall be punishable by imprisonment. 9 Geo. II. c. 5; 5 Geo. IV. c. 83, § 4. See 1 Harris' Life of Lord Hardwicke, 281; and 4 Broom. & H. Com. 70, 205; 4 Steph. Com. (7 edit.) 210. WINDOW TAX-A tax on windows, levied on houses which contained more than six windows, and were worth more than five pounds per annum; established by 7 Will. III. c. 18. or criminal fine. Cowell. VOL. II. 4L

WITCHCRAFTmain

Anderson's Dictionary of Law • 1890

The practices of a witch: a woman (formerly, a man or a woman) supposed to be able to affect the happiness and destiny of other persons by the exercise of supernatural power acquired from intercourse with evil spirits; conjuration; sorcery; enchantment. "A species of offense," says Blackstone, "against God and religion, of which one knows not well what account to give, is witchcraft, conjuration, enchant 309-10 (1888); Hatcher v. Hatcher, 80 Va. 171 (1885), cases; 50 Mich. 460; 74 Me. 413; 100 Pa. 481; 102 id. 247; 16 S. C. 227; 17 id. 348. As to testamentary capacity, in addition to the references to "influence" and "insanity" (ad fin.), see 34 Alb. Law J. 4-7 (1886), cases; 4 Law Quar. Rev. 442-48 (1888), Eng. cases; formalities as to execution, 34 Alb. Law J. 485-88 (1886), cases; execution, authentication, and construction, 26 Cent. Law J. 151-56 (1880), cases; implied revocation of, ib. 387-91 (1888), cases; costs in contested cases, 18 id. 83-86 (1884), cases; lost wills, 39 Alb. Law J. 44-47, 64-67 (1888), cases; distribution of assets in cases of erroneous construction, 23 id. 582 (1886) --- Irish Law Times. ment or sorcery. The thing is a truth to which every nation hath borne testimony, by examples seemingly well attested or by prohibitory laws." The civil law punished with death sorcerers and those who consulted with them, imitating the Mosaic law "Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live" [by her craft?] Our own [English] laws have been equally penal, condemning culprits to the flames. Statute 33 Henry VIII (1542), c. 8. made witchcraft and sorcery felony without benefit of clergy; and 1 James I (1603), c. 12, enacted that persons invoking any evil spirit, or consulting, covenanting with, entertaining, employing, feeding, or rewarding any evil spirit, or hurting any person by such infernal arts, should be guilty of felony without benefit of clergy, and suffer death; and that if any person attempted by sorcery to discover hidden treasure, to restore hidden goods, to provoke unlawful love, or to hurt any man or beast, he or she should suffer imprisonment and pillory for the first offense, and death for the second. Not a few of those executed under these laws confessed guilt at the gallows. Louis XIV of France forbade the courts to receive informations of witchcraft. Statute 9 Geo. III (1769), c. 5, disallowed prosecutions for conjuration, witchcraft, sorcery, or enchantment. But pretending to use witchcraft, tell fortunes, or discover stolen goods, by skill in the occult sciences, is still a punishable misdemeanor in England, and in the States.

WITCHCRAFTn.

Websters Unabridged Dictionary (1913) • 1913

The practices or art of witches; sorcery; enchantments; intercourse with evil spirits. Power more than natural; irresistible influence. He hath a witchcraft Over the king in 's tongue. Shak.

witchcraftnoun

Wiktionary (English) • 2026

Wiktionary contributors • CC BY-SA 4.0 • via Kaikki
Extracted and formatted for display by Law Mind. Source link opens the current Wiktionary page and its contributor history; it is not a frozen copy of this extract.

The practice of witches; magic, sorcery, or the use of supernatural powers to influence or predict events. | Black magic; the use of witchcraft for evil means. | Something, such as an advanced technology, that seems almost magical. | An irresistible or seemingly magical influence.

Explore the full Law Mind legal research platform.

Subscribe Encyclopedia Sign In