SUBMISSION

7 definitions found across Law Mind sources

SUBMISSIONAuthored
The Law Mind • 1101 words
Definition
Submission has two distinct legal meanings that operate in different procedural contexts. 1. SUBMISSION TO AUTHORITY: The act of yielding to legal authority or jurisdiction. A person submits to the laws of a sovereign, to the orders of a court, or to the personal jurisdiction of a tribunal. In this sense, submission is less a discrete legal act than a recognition of obligation or a waiver of objection — particularly relevant when a party voluntarily appears before a court or complies with a judgment. 2. SUBMISSION TO ARBITRATION: An agreement — typically written — by which parties to a dispute consent to refer that dispute to one or more arbitrators for resolution, binding themselves in advance to abide by the arbitral award. This is the dominant legal usage and the one with the most technical development. The submission agreement defines the arbitrators' authority: it frames the issues to be decided, designates the arbitrator(s), and establishes the parties' mutual obligation to perform whatever is awarded. A submission to arbitration is both a contract and a procedural mechanism, and it can take several forms — oral agreement, written contract, bond, deed, or indenture with mutual covenants. ---
Common Language
Modern common usage (Wiktionary): A subset or component of a mission. Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): The act of submitting; yielding to power or authority; surrender of the person and power to the control or government of another; also, the state of being submissive; meekness; resignation. The Webster's sense captures the general meaning of submission as yielding or deference — which does carry over into the first legal definition above. But neither common meaning reaches the specialized procedural sense of submission as a formal arbitration agreement. A researcher encountering "submission" in 18th- or 19th-century legal records must determine from context whether the term refers to general obedience to authority or to the technical arbitration instrument. The two meanings look similar on the surface but carry entirely different legal consequences. ---
Recognized Forms
/SUBTYPES Historical sources, particularly Bouvier, identify the following forms a submission to arbitration could take: - ORAL SUBMISSION: Valid at common law but disfavored due to evidentiary instability. - WRITTEN AGREEMENT (NOT UNDER SEAL): The most common form. Required in Louisiana and California under early statutes. - SUBMISSION BY INDENTURE: Mutual covenants by both parties in a single instrument. - SUBMISSION BY DEED-POLL: Executed by one party only. - SUBMISSION BY BOND: Each party executes a separate obligation to the other, conditioned on performance of the award. The form mattered: it affected revocability, enforceability, and the scope of the arbitrator's authority. ---
Why It Matters in Research
The arbitration sense of submission is the term you will encounter most often in older equity and commercial records, and it requires careful attention to two research problems. First, scope and revocability. A submission to arbitration was historically revocable before an award was made — either party could withdraw consent. This was a significant limitation on arbitration's utility, and it generated a body of case law on when a submission had been properly revoked and what consequences followed. Modern arbitration law (particularly after the Federal Arbitration Act of 1925 and equivalent state statutes) eliminated or sharply curtailed this revocability. Researchers working with pre-20th-century sources will encounter the revocability doctrine as a live issue; it is largely a historical artifact today. Second, scope of the arbitrable issues. The submission defined the arbitrator's jurisdiction. Awards that exceeded the submission were void or voidable. Courts scrutinized submissions carefully to determine whether a particular dispute fell within their terms. Bouvier's discussion of what controversies could be submitted — debts, personal injuries, questions of law, construction of wills and instruments — reflects genuine jurisdictional limits that were litigated. Researchers tracing arbitration disputes should always locate the submission instrument itself, not just the award. In the constitutional and jurisdictional sense, submission also appears in personal jurisdiction analysis. A party who appears in a court without challenging jurisdiction has "submitted" to that court's authority — a concept that connects to waiver doctrine and the history of in personam jurisdiction. ---
Historical Dictionary Support
The historical sources converge on the arbitration definition as primary. Burrill is the clearest: submission is an agreement consenting to submit differences to an arbitrator, usually written, usually by bond, but neither strictly required. Black's (2nd Ed.) defines it as a covenant naming arbitrators and binding parties to perform what is arbitrated — effectively the same formulation. Bouvier adds the most procedural depth, enumerating the forms a submission could take and the range of controversies that could be submitted. His treatment reflects the active doctrinal work courts were doing in the 19th century to map arbitration's boundaries — what subjects were arbitrable, what formalities were required by local law, and what defects would void a submission. All sources treat submission in the authority-yielding sense briefly, almost as a preamble to the arbitration definition. None develops that meaning into a full doctrinal framework, which signals that it functioned more as a general legal concept than as a technical term of art in its own right. What the historical sources do not address: the transformation of submission doctrine under modern arbitration statutes. The shift from revocable common-law submission to statutory arbitration agreements — and eventually to mandatory arbitration clauses in contracts — is post-1900 and outside the scope of these dictionaries. Researchers should not assume historical submission doctrine maps cleanly onto modern arbitration agreement analysis. ---
Jurisdictional Note
Historical statutory requirements varied. Louisiana and California required submissions to arbitration to be in writing; other jurisdictions recognized oral submissions as valid, though inconvenient. Modern arbitration law is more uniform but still varies between federal (FAA) and state regimes, particularly on questions of unconscionability and the arbitrability of specific claim types. ---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
Law Mind Encyclopedia — Arbitration Law Mind Encyclopedia — Alternative Dispute Resolution Law Mind Encyclopedia — Personal Jurisdiction (for the submission-as-waiver context) ---
Related Terms
ARBITRATION — the process a submission initiates AWARD — the output a submission binds parties to accept COVENANT — the contractual form a submission typically takes AGREEMENT TO ARBITRATE — modern statutory equivalent of a submission WAIVER — overlaps with submission in the jurisdictional-consent sense REVOCATION — the historical doctrine permitting withdrawal of a submission before award JURISDICTION — relevant to both the arbitration and the authority-yielding senses CONSENT — foundational concept underlying submission in both senses ARBITRATOR — the decision-maker designated by the submission
SUBMISSIONmain
Black's Law Dictionary • 1891
A yielding to authority. A citizen is bound to submit to the laws; a child to his parents. In practice.
SUBMISSIONmain
Black's Law Dictionary (2nd Ed.) • 1910
A yielding to authority. A citizen is bound to submit to the laws; a child to his parents. In practice. A submission is a covenant by which persons who have a lawsuit or difference with one another name arbitrators to decide the matter, and bind themselves reciprocally to perform what shall be arbitrated. Civ. Code La. art.*3099; Garr v. Gomez, 9 Wend. (N. Y.) 661; District of Columbia v. Bailey, 171 U. S. 161, 18 Sup. Ct. 868, 43 L. Ed. 118; Chorpenning v. U. S., 11 Ct. Cl. 628; Shed v. Railroad Co., 67 Mo. 687. In maritime law. Submission on the part of the vanquished, and complete possession on the part of the victor, transfer property as between belligerents. The Alexander, 1 Gall. 532, Fed. Cas. No. 164. —Submission bond. The bond by which the parties agree to submit their matters to arbitration, and by which they bind themselves to abide by the award of the arbitrator, is commonly called a “‘submission bond.’ Brown.
SUBMISSIONmain
Bouvier's Law Dictionary • 1928
It may be oral, but this is inconvenient, because open to disputes; by written agree- ment not under seal (in Louisiana and California the submission must be in writ- ing; 5 La. 133; 2 Cal. 92); by indenture, with mutual covenants to abide by the de- cision of the arbitrator; by deed-poll, or by bond, each party executing an obligation to the other conditioned to be void respect- ively upon the performance of the award; Caldw. Arb. 16; 6 Watts 357. A parol submission followed by a valid award, though not in writing, may be binding and contlusive upon the parties, if the arbi- trators act fairly, but before a party is so bound, the agreement to arbitrate must be duly established; 97 Ala. 52. An offer to arbitrate not accepted by the other party cannot affect his right to sue; 67 Mo. App. 559; where a submission was provided for in a lease, and by failure of the parties to agree upon arbitrators, nothing had been done and suit was brought, the action could be defeated by an offer at the trial to proceed with the ar- bitration; 12 App. Div. N. Y. 421. A stat- utory provision for arbitration has been held not to be exclusive of the common- law right to arbitrate; 50 Neb. 858. See also, as to the effect of statutory provisions upon common-law arbitration, 119 N. Y. 475; 80 Ala. 118. When to be made. A submission may be made at any time of causes not in court, and at common law, where a cause was depending, submission might be made by rule of court before the trial, or by order of nisi prius after it had commenced, which was afterwards made a rule of court; 2 B. & Ald. 395; 3 S. & R. 262; 4 Halst. 198. Who may make. Any one capable of making a a disposition of his property or release of his right, or capable of suing or being sued, may make a binding submis- sion to arbitration; but one under civil or natural incapacity cannot be bound by his submission; Russ. Arb. 20; 2 P. Wms. 45; 9 Ves. 350; 8 Me. 315; 2 N. H. 484; 8 Vt. 472; 16 Mass. 396; 5 Conn. 367; 1 Barb. 584; 2 Rob. Va. 761; 6 Munf. 458; Paine 646; 5 How. 83. In general, in cases of incapacity of the real owner of property, as well as in many cases of agency, the person who has the legal control of the property may make submission, including a husband for his wife; 5 Ves. 846; a parent or guardian for an infant; Freem. 62, 139; 11 Me. 326; 12 Conn. 376; 3 Caines 253 (but not a guardian ad litem; 9 Humphr. 129); a trustee for his cestui que trust; 3 Esp. 101; an attorney for his client; 1 Ld. Raym. 246; 12 Ala. 252; 9 Pa. 101; 2 Hill, N. Y. 271; 4 Т. В. Monr. 375; 7 Cra. 436 (but see 6 Weekl. Rep. 10); an agent duly authorized for his principal; 8 B. & C. 16; 8 Vt. 472; 11 Mass. 449; 5 Green N. J. 38; 29 Ν. Η. 405; 8 N. Y. 160; an executor or administrator at his own peril, but not thereby necessa- rily admitting assets; 20 Pick. 584; 6 Leigh 62: 5 T. B. Monr. 240: 5 Conn. 621; 1 Barb. 419; 3 Harr. N. J. 442; assignees under bankruptcy and insolvency laws, under the statutory restrictions, stat. 6 Geo. IV. c. 16, and state statutes; the right being limited in all cases to that which the person acting can control and legally dispose of; 6 Mass. 78; 6 Munf. 453; 4 T. B. Monr. 240; 21 Miss. 133; but not including a partner, for a partnership; 1 Cr. M. & R. 681; 1 Pet. 221; 19 Johns. 187; 2 N. Η. 284; 5 Gill & J. 412; 12 S. & R. 243; Lind. Partn. 129, 272; 3 Kent 49; the adminis- tratrix of a public contractor may join in a submission to arbitration of a controversy arising out of the contract; 9 App. D. C. 360. What may be included in a submission. Generally, any matter which the parties might adjust by agreement, or which may be the subject of an action or suit at law, except perhaps actions (qui tam) on penal statutes by common informers; for crimes cannot be made the subject of adjustment and composition by arbitration, this being against the most obvious policy of the law; 5 Wend. 111; 2 Rawle 341; 7 Conn. 345;
SUBMISSIONn.
Websters Unabridged Dictionary (1913) • 1913
The act of submitting; the act of yielding to power or authority; surrender of the person and power to the control or government of another; obedience; compliance. Submission, dauphin! 't is a mere French word; We English warrious wot not what it means. Shak. The state of being submissive; acknowledgement of inferiority or dependence; humble or suppliant behavior; meekness; resignation. In all submission and humility York doth present himself unto your highness. Shak. No duty in religion is more justly required by God . . . than a perfect submission to his will in all things. Sir W. Temple. Acknowledgement of a fault; confession of error. Be not as extreme in submission As in offense. Shak. An agreement by which parties engage to submit any matter of controversy between them to the decision of arbitrators. Wharton (Law Dict.). Bouvier.
submissionnoun
Wiktionary (English) • 2026
Wiktionary contributorsCC BY-SA 4.0 • via Kaikki
Extracted and formatted for display by Law Mind. Source link opens the current Wiktionary page and its contributor history; it is not a frozen copy of this extract.
A subset or component of a mission.
submissionnoun
Wiktionary (English) • 2026
Wiktionary contributorsCC BY-SA 4.0 • via Kaikki
Extracted and formatted for display by Law Mind. Source link opens the current Wiktionary page and its contributor history; it is not a frozen copy of this extract.
The act of submitting or yielding; surrender. | The act of submitting or giving e.g. a completed piece of work. | The thing which has been submitted. | A submission hold in wrestling, mixed martial arts, or other combat sports.

Explore the full Law Mind legal research platform.

SubscribeEncyclopediaSign In