Definition
In pleading and drafting, to set out means to recite, narrate, allege, or incorporate facts, circumstances, or documents within a pleading or legal instrument. When a party sets out a deed, contract, or other instrument, they either quote it verbatim or describe its terms with sufficient particularity to bring its contents before the court.
The phrase operates as a term of art in pleading practice, signaling that a party is doing more than merely referencing a document in passing — they are formally placing its substance into the record. Courts have distinguished between pleadings that adequately set out an instrument (satisfying pleading requirements) and those that merely allude to one (which may be insufficient).
---
Common Language
Modern common usage (Wiktionary): To explain something or give exact details, usually in writing; to begin an activity with the intention of finishing it; to position or arrange something.
Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): To start out; to enter upon a course; to describe or exhibit.
The gap between common and legal usage is narrower here than for many terms, but it matters in context. Ordinary usage allows "set out" to mean simply beginning something or giving a general explanation. Legal usage demands more: to set out a document or fact in a pleading is a formal act with procedural consequences. A pleading that casually "mentions" a contract has not set it out. The legal meaning carries a precision that the common meaning does not require.
---
Why It Matters in Research
Researchers working in historical pleading materials — particularly common law forms, chancery practice, and early federal procedure — will encounter "set out" as a technical standard. Whether a party properly set out an instrument determined whether the pleading survived demurrer. This was not a stylistic choice but a pleading sufficiency question.
Under code pleading reforms in the nineteenth century and later under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the strict requirement to set out instruments verbatim was relaxed in many jurisdictions — a party could attach a copy or plead legal effect. Researchers reading pre-code decisions should not assume that modern notice-pleading standards applied. A case dismissing a claim for failure to "set out" the relevant contract may reflect a strict technical rule no longer operative.
In transactional and drafting contexts, "set out" also appears in instruments as a verb of specification — "as set out in Schedule A," "the terms set out herein" — carrying no special pleading meaning but still signaling formal enumeration or incorporation. Researchers should distinguish these uses from the pleading-specific sense.
The first Black's edition entry for "set out" appears embedded in a passage discussing setoff doctrine, which reflects how the first edition organized certain entries. Researchers consulting that source should be careful not to conflate the brief procedural gloss on "set out" with the surrounding substantive discussion of counterclaims and setoffs — they are editorially adjacent but conceptually distinct.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Both the first and second editions of Black's Law Dictionary define "set out" identically in its pleading sense: to recite or narrate facts or circumstances; to allege, aver, describe, or incorporate — illustrated by the example of setting out a deed or contract. The second edition adds supporting case citations, grounding the definition in actual judicial usage.
The first edition's entry is notable for its placement: it appears in proximity to material on setoff and counterclaims, which could mislead a reader scanning quickly. The definition itself is unambiguous, but the editorial context is potentially confusing.
Neither edition addresses the transactional or drafting usage of "set out" as a term of incorporation by reference, which had become common in instrument drafting by the time both editions were published. Researchers relying solely on these sources for drafting guidance should supplement with practice-specific materials.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
The Law Mind Contracts & Commercial Law Encyclopedia: Assignment of Rights — Rights of Assignee Against Obligor (Defenses, Set-Offs) [contracts_103] — relevant where the proper setting out of assigned instruments in pleadings intersects with setoff defenses.
---