JUSTICES IN EYRE

4 definitions found across Law Mind sources

JUSTICES IN EYREAuthored
The Law Mind • 952 words
Definition
Justices in eyre (also written justices in eire) were itinerant royal judges in medieval England who travelled on circuit through the counties of the kingdom to hear and determine legal causes on behalf of the Crown. Established in their recognizable form under Henry II by the Assize of Northampton (1176), they rode set circuits — England being divided into several districts for this purpose — and typically completed a full tour of the kingdom once every seven years. Their commission could be general (ad omnia placita, authorizing them to hear all manner of pleas) or limited to specific matters, such as taking assizes of novel disseisin or determining pleas of the Crown. They are sometimes called justices itinerant or justices errant in the sources, terms used interchangeably in the historical literature. The eyre was not merely a judicial proceeding but also a fiscal and administrative instrument of the Crown. Justices in eyre collected revenues, fines, and amercements, inquired into local administration, and audited the conduct of local officials. Their arrival in a county was a major event — and often a dreaded one — for local communities, who faced heavy financial exactions as part of the proceeding. The institution declined as the common law courts at Westminster became more developed and as specialized commissions (notably commissions of assize, oyer and terminer, and gaol delivery) took over discrete judicial functions. The eyre had effectively ceased by the mid-fourteenth century.
Common Confusion
Justices in eyre are frequently confused with justices of assize, justices of the peace, and other itinerant commissions. The distinctions matter for corpus research. Justices of assize operated under narrower, more specialized commissions and eventually replaced the general eyre as the primary mechanism of circuit justice. Justices of the peace were local, not itinerant, and held a permanent appointment within a county rather than traveling on royal commission. The eyre, by contrast, was a comprehensive visitation of royal authority — broader in scope than any of its successor forms. Bouvier's entry on "Justice" covers the justice of the peace in considerable detail; care is needed not to import that definition backward onto the eyre institution.
Why It Matters in Research
This term appears almost exclusively in pre-1400 English legal history and in the historical legal dictionaries that engage with that period. Researchers encountering it in primary sources or treatises should note several navigational points. First, terminology is unstable across sources. The Latin forms — justiciarii in itinere, justiciarii itinerantes, justiciarii errantes — appear alongside the Anglo-French "eyre" or "eire" in the same documents and secondary commentaries. Burrill preserves the Latin variants explicitly; Bouvier does not. A search limited to one form will miss material filed under others. Second, the seven-year circuit interval is a useful anchor for dating events in narrative sources. References to a county "awaiting the eyre" or recording amercements from a recent eyre can help establish approximate dates when other dating evidence is thin. Third, the fiscal dimension of the eyre is often underweighted in legal dictionary treatments, which foreground the judicial function. For researchers working on medieval Crown finance, local administration, or the history of royal prerogative, the eyre records (the plea rolls and coroners' rolls associated with eyres) are a distinct archival category, not simply court records. Fourth, the eyre's decline is gradual and uneven in the sources. Some historical dictionaries treat the institution as continuous into the late medieval period; others effectively stop their treatment at Edward I's reign, when the eyre was most systematically deployed. Researchers should be alert to sources that conflate the formal eyre with later special commissions that borrowed its procedural vocabulary. Finally, because justices in eyre operated before the common law had fully systematized, their records and procedures are the subject of specialized legal historical scholarship (notably the work of Helen Cam and Doris Stenton) that sits outside the standard legal dictionary tradition entirely. The dictionary entries in this corpus are useful orientation but are not substitutes for that scholarship when primary engagement with eyre records is required.
Historical Dictionary Support
Bouvier and Burrill agree on the essentials: itinerant royal judges, circuits of the kingdom, commission either general or special, established in recognizable form under Henry II. Burrill supplies the more useful Latin terminology and explicitly notes the commission variant ad omnia placita, which signals a general eyre as opposed to a special purpose visitation. Bouvier provides the date of 1176 and the detail that three justices were appointed to each circuit — a structural point Burrill omits. Both dictionaries treat the institution as primarily judicial and give little attention to its fiscal and administrative functions, which modern legal historians regard as equally central to the eyre's purpose and to the Crown's motivation for maintaining it. Neither dictionary traces the institution's decline in any detail, and neither engages with the records it produced or the procedural law governing eyre proceedings. The Bouvier cross-references to Burn, Davis, Graydon, and Comyn's Digest are oriented toward the justice of the peace, not the eyre, and should not be followed as sources on the eyre institution itself.
Jurisdictional Note
The justices in eyre were specific to medieval England and have no parallel in other common law jurisdictions. The institution did not transplant to the American colonies or to other parts of the British Empire, and it had no successor in any living jurisdiction. Research involving this term is by definition historical and England-specific.
Related Terms
Assize — Eyre — Justice of the Peace — Justices of Assize — Oyer and Terminer — Gaol Delivery — Nisi Prius — Itinerant Justice — Plea Rolls — Pleas of the Crown — Commission (judicial) — Circuit (judicial)
JUSTICES IN EYREmain
Bouvier's Law Dictionary • 1928
See, generally, Burn; Davis; Graydon, Justice; Bache, Manual of a Justice of the Peace; Comyn, Dig.; 15 Viner, Abr. 3; Bacon, Abr.; 2 Sell. Pr. 70; 2 Phil. Ev. 239; Chitty, Pr.; 11 Myer, Fed. Dig. 773. In English Law. One of several persons who are appointed by the Crown to be, or who ex officio are, justices within a certain district, as a county or a borough, for the conservation of the peace, and for the execution of divers things comprehended within their commission and within divers statutes committed to their charge. They act either ministerially or judicially, minis- terially in cases of felony or misdemeanor, where they merely initiate the proceedings by issuing a warrant of apprehension, taking the depositions, and committing for trial; judicially in quarter sessions (q. v.), and in all cases where they have summary jurisdic- tion, whether criminal or civil. Byrne. See
JUSTICES IN EYREmain
Bouvier's Law Dictionary • 1928
Certain judges established, if not first appointed, A. D. 1176, 22 Hen. II. England was divided into certain circuits, and three justices in eyre or justices itinerant, as they were sometimes called-were appointed to each dis trict, and made the circuit of the kingdom once in seven years, for the purpose of trying causes. They were afterwards, when the the judicial functions assumed greater importance, directed, by Magna Charta, c. 12, to be sent into every county once a year. The itinerant justices were sometimes more Justices of assize or dower, or of general jail de livery, and the like. Speaking of the 12th century it is said that "the visitation of the counties by itinerant justices has been becoming systematic." The holding of the assize on circuit was evidently committed to judges of great prominence. "From the early years of the reign (Henry II.) we hear of pleas held on cir- cuit by Richard Lucy the chief justiciar, by Henry of Essex the constable, and by Thomas Becket the chancellor... In 1176, to execute the assize of Northampton, eighteen justices were employed, and the country was divided into six circuits; in 1179, twenty-one justices were employed, and the country was divided into four circuits; Indeed from 1176 onwards hardly a year went by without there. being a visitation of some part of England. These Itinerant Justices seem to have been chiefly em- ployed in hearing the pleas of the crown (for which purpose they were equipped with the power of obtaining accusations from the local juries), and in entertaining some or all of the new possessory ac- tions. The court that they held was, as already said, curia regis, but it was not capitalis curia regis, and probably their powers were limited by the words of a temporary commission. They were not necessarily members of the central court, and they might be summoned before it to bear record of their doings; still it was usual that each party of Justices should include some few members of the permanent tribunal." 1 Poll. & Maitl. 184. These justices in eyre in the reign of Henry III. are thus described: "E "But we may distinguish the main types of these commissions. What seems treated as the humblest is the commission to de- liver a jail. This is done very frequently; generally it is done by some three or four knights of the shire, and thus long before the institution of justices of the peace, the country knights had been accustomed to do high criminal justice. In order to dispose of the possessory assizes of novel disseisin and mort d'ancestor, a vast number of commissions were issued in every year. Early in Henry's reign this work was often entrusted to four knights of the shire; at a later time one of the permanent jus- tices would usually be named and allowed to asso- ciate sorne knights with himself. Apparently a Justice of assize had often to visit many towns or even villages in each county; he did not do all his work at the county town. It must have been heavy work, for these actions were extremely popular. In the second year of Edward's reign some two thou- sand commissions of assize were issued. Just at that time the practice seems to have been to divide England into four circuits and to send two justices of assize round each circuit; but a full history of the circuits would be intricate and wearisome. Above all the other commissions rank the commis- sion for an iter ad omnia placita, or more briefly for an iter, or eyre. An eyre had come to be a long and laborious business. In the first place, if we suppose an eyre in Cambridgeshire announced, this has the effect of stopping all Cambridgeshire busi- ness in the bench. Litigants who have been told to appear before the justices at Westminster will now have to appear before the justices in eyre at Cam- bridgeshire. There is no business before the bench at Westminster if an eyre has been proclaimed in all the counties. Then again the justices are pro- vided with a long list of interrogatories (capitula itineris) which they are to address to local juries. Every hundred, overy vill in the county must be represented before them. These interrogatories- their number increases as time goes on ransack the memories of the jurors, and the local records for all that has happened in the shire since the last eyre took place come seven years ago; every crime, every invasion of royal rights, every neglect of police duties must be presented. The justices must sit in the county town from week to week and even from month to month before they will have got through the tedious task and inflicted the due tale of fines ani amercements. Three or four of the permanent judges will be placed in the comamis- sion: with them will be associated some of the magnates of the district; bishops and even abbots, to the scandal of strict churchmen, have to serve as justices in eyre. Probably it was thought expe- dient that some of the great freeholders of the country should be commissioned, in order that no man might say that
JUSTICES IN EYREmain
Burrill's Law Dictionary • 1870
[L. Lat. justiciarii in itinere; justiciarii itinerantes or errantes.] In old English law. Itinerant or travelling justices. Justices who travelled from county to county throughout the kingdom, usually once every seven years, sometimes with a general commission to determine all manner of causes, (ad omnia placita,) and sometimes for certain special purposes, as to take assises of novel disseisin and mort d'ancestor, to deliver the gaols, and sometimes to take a single assise or two, and no more. Bract. fol. 105 b, 108. Bracton gives the forms of their commissions in each of these cases, at length. Id. fol. 109-111 b. They were first regularly established in the time of Henry II. 3 Bl. Com. 57. 1 Spence's Chancery, 115, 116.

Explore the full Law Mind legal research platform.

SubscribeEncyclopediaSign In