ISSUE ROLL - The Law Mind Legal Dictionary

ISSUE ROLLAuthored

The Law Mind • 943 words

Definition

An issue roll was a formal record in English common law practice upon which the issue in an action at law was required to be entered once the pleadings had been joined. The roll was titled (or "entitled") with the term in which the issue was joined. When an issue was triable by the country (i.e., by jury), it was not the practice to enter the issue at full length on the roll until after the trial had concluded; prior to trial, only an incipitur — a brief noting that the entry had been begun — was made. The issue roll was a survival of the ancient oral pleading system, in which court clerks recorded proceedings on parchment rolls contemporaneously with the parties' oral exchanges before the court. By the nineteenth century, the physical practice had long fallen into disuse, but the courts continued to treat the roll as existing in legal contemplation. The issue roll was formally abolished by the Rules of Hilary Term, 1834.

Common Confusion

The issue roll is sometimes loosely conflated with other rolls of the English common law courts, such as the plea roll or the nisi prius record. These are distinct instruments. The plea roll recorded the full course of pleadings; the nisi prius record was a certified extract sent to the trial court. The issue roll had a narrower, specific function: to memorialize the point at which the pleadings had crystallized into a triable issue. Researchers encountering references to "the roll" in pre-1834 English procedural texts should identify which roll is meant, as the terminology is not always consistent across treatises.

Why It Matters in Research

The issue roll is almost exclusively a term of English common law procedure and appears in sources dealing with pre-1834 practice. Researchers will encounter it primarily in treatises on common law pleading and practice — Tidd's Practice is the central authority cited by all four source dictionaries — and in historical accounts of English court procedure.

Several research traps are worth noting. First, because the physical practice of making up the issue roll had decayed long before its formal abolition, sources from the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries may describe it either as a living requirement or as a legal fiction sustained by convention; these descriptions are not contradictory but reflect different moments in the roll's decline. Second, the incipitur notation is easy to overlook: researchers reading pre-trial procedural records may find only this placeholder rather than a full entry, which can create a false impression that the record is incomplete. Third, the abolition date of 1834 (Hilary Term rules) is a clean terminus: any source describing the issue roll as a current procedural requirement postdates that point only if it is discussing historical practice or legal contemplation, not operative procedure.

American common law practice largely adopted English pleading forms in the colonial and early national periods, but the issue roll as a distinct instrument did not take root in American courts to the same degree. Researchers working in early American state court records should not assume the issue roll will appear as a distinct document even where English pleading forms were otherwise followed.

The Law Mind corpus connections here run primarily through historical English procedure materials. The term has no meaningful connection to modern practice and should be treated as a research artifact useful for understanding the architecture of common law pleading systems rather than as a living procedural concept.

Historical Dictionary Support

The four source dictionaries show strong agreement on the basic definition and converge on Tidd's Practice (volume 2) as the authoritative procedural reference. Bouvier adds the crucial abolition date — Hilary Term, 1834 — citing Mozley & Whiteley's Dictionary, making it the most practically useful entry for a researcher trying to date the term's operative life. Rapalje & Lawrence offer the most historically rich account, situating the roll within the broader practice of oral pleading and explaining why the roll persisted as a legal fiction after it ceased to be a practical reality: the courts required it to be "made up, or at all events" recognized in contemplation. This passage, though truncated in the source material, captures the essential tension between living procedure and legal ceremony that characterized the roll in its final decades.

Burrill reproduces language closely parallel to Black's, both drawing directly from Tidd. Neither Black's nor Burrill adds substantially to what Rapalje and Bouvier provide, though Burrill's entry is notable for a textual artifact — an apparent compositor's error or OCR corruption inserting the phrase "Ita te Deus adjuvet et omnes sancti" (the juryman's oath language) mid-entry, which confirms that researchers should treat digitized versions of Burrill with some caution for accuracy.

What the historical dictionaries collectively omit is any sustained treatment of the incipitur practice or guidance on what surviving issue rolls or incipitur notations actually look like in archival collections — a gap that researchers working with primary sources will need to fill through paleographic and archival guides to the English common law courts.

Jurisdictional Note

The issue roll is a term of English common law procedure only. It was formally abolished in England by the Hilary Term Rules of 1834. American jurisdictions did not adopt this particular instrument as a distinct procedural form, and the term does not appear in American statutory or case law as an operative concept.

ISSUE ROLLmain

Black's Law Dictionary • 1891

In English practice. A roll upon which the issue in actions at law was formerly required to be entered, the roll being entitled of the term in which the issue was joined. 2 Tidd, Pr. 733. It was not, however, the practice to enter the issue at full length, if triable by the country, until after the trial, but only to make an incipitur on the roll. Id. 734.

ISSUE ROLLmain

Rapalje & Lawrence • 1888

-In ancient times it was the practice of the English courts, when the pleadings were carried on orally, to have a coni temporaneous record of the proceedings made out upon a parchment roll called the "Issue Roll." This practice, although long grown into disuse, was until recently still supposed in contemplation of law to exist; and the courts still required that it should be made up, or at all events commenced, or an incipitur (q. v.) entered upon the roll, and certain fees were paid to the officers for making it up. Practically, however, this roll was of no use, and, in consequence, it was abolished; and the only entry of the proceedings upon record came to be that upon the Nisi Prius Record, or upon the Judgment Roll, according to the nature of the case. (1 Pl. R. H. T. 4 Will. IV.) And at the present day, there appears to be no issue roll at all in use, unless it should be in the House of Lords. See ENTRY ON THE ROLL, Jones (N. C.) L. 425; 3 Binn. (Pa.) 160, 161; 70 Pa. St. 72; 79 Id. 333, 335; 11 Phil. (Pa.) 623; 1 Serg. & R. (Pa.) 155; 14 Id. 40; 3 Whart. (Pa.) 215; 2 Yeates (Pa.) 585; 3 Desaus. (S. C.) 165; 2 Wash. (Va.) 31; 4 Wheel. Am. C. L. 371; 1 Am. L. J. 1933 8 Bing. 386; Cas. t. Talb. 3-10; 6 Hare 239; 8 L. J. N. S. Ch. 60; 9 Ch. D. 131; L. R. 2 C. P. 511; L. R. 1 H. L. 175; 1 Ld. Raym. 203, 205; 1 P. Wms. 500. 144; 1 Saund. 185 n.; 3 T. R. 86; 4 Id. 294; 5 Id. 299; 2 Vern. 545; 3 Ves. 383; 1 Hov. Sup. 309, 341. Ves. 274, 275; 3 Ves. & B. 67; 2 Wils. 6, 7; 8 Com. Dig. 473; Reeve Dom. Rel. 469. (in pleading, defined). 5 Pet. (U. S.) 141; 7 Humph. (Tenn.) 532. (Mass.) 206. (in pleading, what is not). 5 Pick. (in practice act). 109 Mass. 211. ISSUE, DYING WITHOUT, (in a devise). Wash. (U. S.) 369. ISSUE, GENERAL, (in assumpsit). 2 Hill (N. Υ.) 478. ISSUED, (as to process). 8 How. (N. Y.) Pr. (of bank notes). 17 Barb. (Ν. Υ.) (when does not mean "levied"). Wilberf. Stat. L. 131. (when writ is). 9 Wend. (N. Υ.) 209, ISSUES AND PROFITS, (in a will). 5 Mod. 63. ISSUES AND PROFITS OF LAND, (in a will). 1 Cro. 190. ISSUING, (distinguished from "paying out"). 38 Mich. 104. ISSUE, IN DEFAULT OF SUCH, (in a will). 1 Meriv. 675. ISSUE, LEAVING, (in a will). L. R. 7 Eq. 472. ISSUE, LIVING, (in a will). 2 Atk. 12, 13. ISSUE MALE, (as meaning "heirs male"). 5 T. R. 305; 4 Ves. 794. ISSUE MALE AND FEMALE, (in a devise). Beav. 100. ISSUE MALE OF HIS BODY, (in a will). Wils. 322, 323. (in a statute). Chit. Bills 209. ISSUING OF NOTES, (in a statute). 2 Hall (N. Υ.) 519. ISSUING OF A WRIT, (in a statute, synonymous with granting it). 19 Wend. (N. Y.) 49. IT APPEARS PRESUMPTIVELY, (in code of procedure). 61 How. (N. Y.) Pr. 371. IT SHALL AND MAY BE LAWFUL, (not neces sarily imperative). 1 Edw. (N. Y.) 84. IT SHALL BE LAWFUL, (in a statute). 5 App. Cas. 214; 4 Q. B. D. 245.

ISSUE ROLLmain

Bouvier's Law Dictionary • 1928

In English Law. The name of a record which contained an entry of issue as soon as it was found. It was abolished by the rules of Hilary Term, 1834. Moz. & W. Dict.

Explore the full Law Mind legal research platform.

Subscribe Encyclopedia Sign In