Definition
A punishment so severe or degrading that it triggers constitutional procedural protections — specifically, the Fifth Amendment requirement that prosecution for any crime punishable by infamous punishment must be initiated by grand jury indictment or presentment. The defining characteristic under American constitutional doctrine is not simply the harshness of the punishment, but its specific quality: imprisonment at hard labor — whether served in a penitentiary or elsewhere — constitutes an infamous punishment in the constitutional sense. Courts have treated the nature of the punishment authorized by law, not merely the punishment actually imposed, as the operative test.
The concept operates primarily as a threshold trigger. Once a crime is classified as punishable by infamous punishment, the grand jury clause of the Fifth Amendment attaches, and the government cannot proceed by information alone in federal prosecutions.
---
Common Confusion
INFAMOUS PUNISHMENT and INFAMOUS CRIME are closely related but technically distinct concepts. An infamous crime is the offense; infamous punishment is what makes it infamous. The two terms are often used interchangeably in older sources, and Bouvier's own entry cross-references them without sharp distinction. Researchers should be alert to this slippage, particularly in nineteenth-century treatises and cases where "infamous crime" is sometimes defined entirely by reference to the punishment it carries — making the two concepts functionally circular in older usage. The cleaner modern framework treats the punishment as the constitutional determinant and the crime as the downstream classification.
INFAMOUS PUNISHMENT should also be distinguished from CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT under the Eighth Amendment. The two doctrines address different constitutional problems: infamous punishment doctrine governs procedural rights at the charging stage (grand jury); cruel and unusual punishment doctrine governs whether a sentence may be imposed at all. A punishment could theoretically be infamous without being cruel and unusual, or vice versa.
---
Why It Matters in Research
This term is primarily a term of Fifth Amendment grand jury jurisprudence, not a freestanding sentencing concept. Researchers encountering it in historical sources should resist reading it through a modern Eighth Amendment lens — the cruel and unusual punishment framework governs a distinct constitutional question.
The key research trap is temporal: the infamous punishment doctrine developed through a cluster of late nineteenth and early twentieth century Supreme Court decisions that fixed imprisonment at hard labor as the constitutional threshold. Bouvier's entry cites cases from 1895, 1885, 1900, and 1922 (163 U.S. 228; 114 U.S. 417; 178 U.S. 304; 258 U.S. 433), reflecting a doctrine that was actively being worked out during those decades. Researchers working in sources from before that line of cases may find "infamous punishment" used more loosely, sometimes referring to pillory, branding, or other historically degrading penalties rather than the hard-labor standard the Supreme Court eventually settled on.
Jurisdictional research requires care: the Fifth Amendment grand jury clause has not been incorporated against the states. State constitutional equivalents may use similar language — "infamous crime" or "infamous punishment" — but define the threshold differently. Do not assume that state cases construing state constitutional provisions track the federal doctrine.
For corpus researchers, this term most productively connects to grand jury indictment requirements, the historical development of penitentiary punishment as distinct from other forms of incarceration, and the procedural architecture of the Fifth Amendment. It surfaces frequently in late nineteenth century federal criminal procedure disputes and in early debates about whether misdemeanor imprisonment could be made to carry the indictment requirement.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Bouvier's definition is compact and doctrine-forward: infamous punishment means imprisonment at hard labor, and the practical consequence is the grand jury requirement under the Fifth Amendment. Bouvier ties the definition directly to Supreme Court authority rather than offering an independent analysis, which is characteristic of the later editions of that dictionary operating in a period when judicial doctrine had begun to displace common law categories.
What Bouvier's entry does not address — and what researchers should supply from other sources — is the historical common law background from which the concept emerged. At common law, infamy carried consequences beyond procedure: an infamous person was incompetent to testify and subject to punishments associated with degradation and civil death, including branding, the pillory, and transportation. The American constitutional doctrine gradually narrowed "infamous" to a functional test centered on incarceration at hard labor, shedding the older common law stigma framework. Bouvier's entry, written after the key Supreme Court decisions, reflects the narrowed doctrine but does not narrate the transition. Researchers relying solely on Bouvier may miss the richer historical meaning that surfaces in earlier authorities.
---
Jurisdictional Note
The Fifth Amendment grand jury clause, which infamous punishment doctrine activates, applies only in federal proceedings. States are not required to use grand juries and may proceed by information for crimes that would require indictment federally. State constitutions with their own infamous crime or infamous punishment provisions vary substantially in how they define the threshold, and those definitions may diverge from the federal hard-labor standard.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
The Law Mind Criminal Law Encyclopedia: Sentencing — Overview and Purposes of Punishment
The Law Mind Constitutional Law Encyclopedia: The Eighth Amendment — Cruel and Unusual Punishment and Evolving Standards of Decency
The Law Mind Criminal Law Encyclopedia: Eighth Amendment — Cruel and Unusual Punishment (Overview)
---