Definition
A gift of personal property is a voluntary, gratuitous transfer of ownership in a chattel (tangible movable property) or chose in action (an intangible right enforceable by legal action) from one living person to another, without consideration. No payment, exchange, or obligation is required or expected. The transfer is complete when three elements converge: donative intent on the part of the giver, delivery of the property, and acceptance by the recipient.
The term encompasses two principal forms based on timing and circumstance:
1. Gift inter vivos — a gift made between living persons, effective immediately and irrevocable once completed.
2. Gift causa mortis — a gift made in contemplation of imminent death, conditional on the donor dying from the anticipated cause; revocable if the donor recovers.
---
Common Language
Modern common usage (Wiktionary): A gift is something given voluntarily without payment in return; a present.
Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): "Something given; a present; a donation; specifically, a voluntary transfer of real or personal property, without any consideration."
The common usage captures the spirit but obscures a critical legal distinction: in ordinary speech, handing something to someone is a gift. In law, that handover is necessary but not sufficient — and sometimes not even literally required. Delivery can be constructive or symbolic, and the legal analysis of whether a gift was validly completed turns on technical doctrines that everyday usage gives no warning of.
---
Core Elements
Three elements are required for a valid, completed gift of personal property. All three must be present; absence of any one defeats the transfer.
1. DONATIVE INTENT: The donor must intend to make a present, unconditional transfer of ownership — not a loan, not a future promise, not a conditional arrangement. Intent is assessed at the moment of transfer, not after the fact.
2. DELIVERY: The donor must relinquish dominion and control. Delivery may be:
- Actual (physical transfer of the object)
- Constructive (transfer of the means of access, such as keys)
- Symbolic (transfer of a document representing the property, where actual delivery is impractical)
3. ACCEPTANCE: The donee must accept the gift. Acceptance is generally presumed where the gift is beneficial, but a donee may decline.
---
Recognized Forms
/SUBTYPES
Gift inter vivos: A completed gift during the donor's lifetime, effective immediately upon delivery and acceptance. Irrevocable once made.
Gift causa mortis: A gift made in anticipation of the donor's death from a specific, impending cause. Revocable by the donor if they survive; automatically revoked if the donor outlives the anticipated peril. Subject to stricter scrutiny and sometimes statutory override by creditors' claims or spousal rights.
---
Why It Matters in Research
The primary research trap here is delivery. Courts and treatises across different eras have varied considerably on how much physical transfer is actually required — particularly for intangibles, for bulky property, and for gifts between family members who share a household. A 19th-century case may apply a strict manual-delivery rule that modern courts have softened, and a researcher applying historical doctrine to a modern fact pattern (or vice versa) will find the results diverge sharply.
The causa mortis form is especially unstable across the corpus. Some historical sources treat it with near-suspicion — as an instrument of deathbed manipulation or fraud — and impose requirements that later jurisdictions relaxed. Others fold it closely into testamentary doctrine, requiring near-will formalities. Researchers working with older materials should not assume that what a treatise says about gifts inter vivos also applies to gifts causa mortis.
Choses in action present a separate complication. Burrill's entry signals that they are included in the definition, but the historical rule was that choses in action were not assignable — a rule that eroded over time. Early sources may treat gifts of intangibles with skepticism or require additional formalities (such as written assignment) that later became standard or unnecessary.
Within the Law Mind corpus, this term connects tightly to trust law (a gift into trust requires its own completion doctrine), to the law of bailment (incomplete gifts can look like bailments), and to estate administration (gifts causa mortis interact directly with probate and creditors' claims).
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Burrill's Law Dictionary defines a gift of personal property as "a voluntary and gratuitous transfer of a chattel or chose in action; which, to be valid and binding, must either be accompanied by..." — the entry appears truncated in available sources, but the opening language is substantively consistent with modern doctrine on the core structure of the gift. The emphasis on voluntariness and gratuitousness aligns with contemporary analysis.
What Burrill's era sources typically do not fully address: the modern flexibility around constructive and symbolic delivery, which expanded significantly in response to the practical difficulty of physically handing over securities, bank accounts, and other financial instruments. Researchers using 19th-century dictionaries will find delivery doctrine described in terms that assume tangible, movable chattels — applying that framework to intangible personal property requires bridging work.
---
Jurisdictional Note
The three-element framework (intent, delivery, acceptance) is uniform across American jurisdictions, but courts diverge on how strictly delivery must be actual versus constructive. Some states apply a demanding physical-transfer rule, particularly for gifts causa mortis; others accept symbolic delivery broadly. In the context of gifts of financial instruments and digital assets, statutory and regulatory overlays now govern in ways that common law gift doctrine does not anticipate.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
Personal Property — Gifts (Inter Vivos, Causa Mortis — Delivery, Intent, Acceptance) (The Law Mind Property Law Encyclopedia) — primary reference for elements, doctrine, and historical development.
Personal Property — Intellectual Property as Personal Property (Overview) (The Law Mind Property Law Encyclopedia) — relevant where the subject of the gift is an intangible such as a copyright interest or patent right.
---