Definition
A declinatory plea was a procedural plea in English criminal practice by which a defendant, before trial or conviction, sought to avoid the jurisdiction or process of the court entirely — not by contesting guilt, but by invoking a privilege that removed the defendant from the ordinary reach of the criminal law. Historically, the two recognized declinatory pleas were:
1. The plea of sanctuary: An assertion that the defendant, having taken refuge in a place of ecclesiastical sanctuary, was immune from secular criminal process and could not lawfully be compelled to stand trial.
2. The plea of benefit of clergy: A claim, interposed before trial, that the defendant was a clerk in holy orders (later extended to anyone who could demonstrate basic literacy) and therefore entitled to be tried in ecclesiastical rather than secular courts, which imposed far lighter penalties.
Both pleas were abolished in English law. Benefit of clergy as a pre-trial declinatory plea was abolished by statute (6 & 7 Geo. IV, c. 28, s. 6). Sanctuary had collapsed as a practical doctrine well before formal abolition. Neither plea has any operative force in modern law.
---
Common Confusion
Declinatory plea should not be confused with dilatory plea. A dilatory plea does not decline the court's jurisdiction outright but seeks to delay or impede the proceedings — for example, by challenging the sufficiency of process or raising a plea in abatement. A declinatory plea goes further: it asks the court to yield the defendant entirely to another forum or to recognize a categorical immunity. In practice, historical sources sometimes use the terms loosely, and researchers consulting older authorities should verify which type of plea is actually being described.
Declinatory plea should also be distinguished from a plea in bar, which defeats the action permanently on substantive grounds (such as former jeopardy), and from a plea to the jurisdiction, which contests the court's subject-matter authority rather than invoking a personal privilege.
---
Why It Matters in Research
This term is almost exclusively a term of historical English law. Researchers are unlikely to encounter it in any operative modern legal context, but it appears with some regularity in historical criminal law materials, ecclesiastical law scholarship, and comparative discussions of the development of criminal procedure.
The key research trap is assuming that "declinatory plea" describes a broader category of pleas that decline jurisdiction — which is how some modern writers loosely use the phrase. The historical legal dictionaries are consistent and narrow: the term referred specifically to sanctuary and benefit of clergy, not to jurisdictional challenges generally. A researcher finding "declinatory plea" in a 19th-century treatise or case report should read it in that precise historical sense.
For corpus researchers, the term connects most directly to benefit of clergy materials, which have a rich documentary history. Benefit of clergy underwent significant evolution — from a genuine ecclesiastical privilege to a near-universal mitigation mechanism that could be pleaded after conviction (at which point it functioned as a sentencing tool, not a declinatory plea at all). The distinction between benefit of clergy pleaded before trial (the declinatory form) and benefit of clergy pleaded after conviction is important and often blurred in secondary sources.
Sanctuary doctrine has its own trajectory and largely disappeared from English practice before formal abolition, making it rarer in case-generated sources but present in treatise literature.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Black's (1st and 2nd editions), Bouvier's, and Burrill's are in close agreement: all three define the term identically, cite the same primary authorities (Hale's Pleas of the Crown and Blackstone's Commentaries), and note abolition. The consistency across dictionaries reflects the narrow, settled, and historical character of the term by the time these works were compiled — it was already a relic.
Bouvier's adds a statutory citation for abolition (6 & 7 Geo. IV, c. 28, s. 6) and cross-references benefit of clergy, which is the more useful entry for researchers who want to trace the full doctrine. Burrill's follows the same formulation as Black's without additional elaboration.
What the historical dictionaries do not address is the broader procedural taxonomy into which declinatory pleas fit — that is, the classification of pleas as dilatory, declinatory, peremptory, or in bar. Blackstone's Commentaries (Book IV, Chapter 26) and Chitty's Criminal Law provide fuller taxonomic treatment and are the appropriate sources for understanding where declinatory pleas sat in the structure of English criminal pleading.
---
Jurisdictional Note
This term has no meaningful application in American law. Benefit of clergy was received into some American colonial and early state courts but was abolished state by state through the 19th century. Sanctuary never took root as a formal legal doctrine in American criminal procedure. The term "declinatory plea" does not appear as an operative category in any U.S. jurisdiction.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
Arraignment and Entry of Plea — The Law Mind Criminal Law Encyclopedia (criminal_198)
---