Definition
A criminal charge is a formal accusation, made through an established legal process, that a specific person has committed a crime. The charge initiates or advances the criminal prosecution and obligates the accused to answer for the alleged conduct before a court.
Criminal charges may allege an act of commission (doing something the law prohibits) or an act of omission (failing to do something the law requires). The charge must identify the offense with sufficient particularity to allow the accused to understand what conduct is at issue and to prepare a defense.
Charges originate through several procedural vehicles: a grand jury indictment, a prosecutor's information, a criminal complaint filed by law enforcement, or, in minor matters, a citation or summons. The vehicle used depends on the jurisdiction and the severity of the offense.
---
Common Language
Modern common usage (Wiktionary): "Charge" in general use means an accusation or allegation against someone, or the price demanded for goods or services. "Criminal charges" in everyday speech loosely means being accused of a crime by police or the government.
Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): "Charge" is defined in part as "an accusation of a wrong or offense," consistent with both lay and legal senses.
The gap here is procedural, not conceptual. In ordinary speech, "criminal charges" can describe any point at which suspicion attaches — an arrest, a police accusation, even public allegation. In legal usage, a criminal charge is a specific, formal legal act with defined consequences: it triggers constitutional protections, imposes duties on the prosecution, and establishes the precise legal and factual claims the accused must answer. Arrest alone does not constitute a charge in the legal sense.
---
Common Confusion
Criminal charges are frequently conflated with arrests and with indictments. An arrest is a physical act of detention; it does not require that charges have been or will be filed. An indictment is one method of bringing charges — specifically, the method used when a grand jury votes to formally accuse. A person can be arrested without charges following, and charges can be brought without a prior arrest. Researchers working with historical records should be attentive to which step in the process a source is actually describing.
---
Core Elements
For an accusation to constitute a criminal charge in the legal sense, it generally must:
1. Identify a specific person as the accused.
2. Allege specific conduct — act or omission — that constitutes a defined crime.
3. Be made in a legally recognized form (indictment, information, complaint, or equivalent).
4. Be brought by a party with authority to prosecute (typically a government actor).
The Sixth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution adds a constitutional dimension: the accused has the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation. This means the charge must be stated with enough specificity to allow preparation of a defense and to bar double jeopardy on the same conduct.
---
Why It Matters in Research
The term "criminal charges" spans every stage of criminal procedure literature — from charging instruments and grand jury practice to constitutional law and sentencing. Several research traps are worth flagging:
Procedural specificity varies by jurisdiction and era. Historical sources often use "charge," "accusation," "indictment," and "information" interchangeably when they are legally distinct acts with different procedural implications. A 19th-century source describing someone as "charged" may mean only that an information was filed by a magistrate, not that a grand jury acted.
The constitutional framework is a central research node. The Sixth Amendment right to be informed of charges, the Fifth Amendment grand jury requirement (for federal felonies), and due process notice requirements together form a constitutional overlay that shapes how charges must be framed and what defects are fatal. Research in constitutional criminal procedure will move quickly from the charging document itself into this doctrine.
Multiple charges and charging strategy matter for sentencing and plea research. Modern criminal practice frequently involves multiple charges arising from a single episode — understanding how charges are aggregated, dismissed, or bargained away is essential context for research in plea bargaining, prosecutorial discretion, and sentencing disparity.
Historical dictionary sources focus on the formal accusation function of charges without engaging the constitutional dimension, which developed substantially through 20th-century case law. Researchers should not expect pre-20th-century dictionary sources to reflect modern Sixth Amendment notice doctrine.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Bouvier's Law Dictionary defines "criminal charges" as "an accusation, made in a legal manner, of illegal conduct, either of omission or commission by the person charged," citing 1 Bush (Ky.) 180. This definition is serviceable and accurate as far as it goes. Its emphasis on legality of manner — that the accusation must be made through proper legal process — captures the core distinction between a mere allegation and a formal charge. The inclusion of both omission and commission is a useful clarification, as lay usage tends to associate charges only with affirmative wrongdoing.
What Bouvier's does not address is the constitutional dimension: the accused's right to notice, the specificity requirements, and the procedural consequences that attach once charges are formally brought. These were less developed at the time of earlier Bouvier's editions and are now central to how courts and practitioners understand what a "charge" must contain and accomplish.
---
Jurisdictional Note
The procedural vehicle for bringing criminal charges differs significantly between federal practice (which requires grand jury indictment for felonies under the Fifth Amendment) and state practice (where most states permit prosecutors to proceed by information without a grand jury, particularly for non-capital offenses). The sufficiency and specificity requirements for charging instruments also vary by state procedural rules and local court practice.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
Sixth Amendment — Right to Be Informed of Charges (The Law Mind Criminal Law Encyclopedia)
---