Definition
Courts of Assize and Nisi Prius were English judicial tribunals composed of royal commissioners — styled judges of assize, or judges of assize and nisi prius — dispatched twice yearly by royal commission to travel circuits throughout the counties of England and Wales. Their primary function was to try, before local juries drawn from the county, questions of fact that had been initiated in the central courts at Westminster Hall but could not practicably be resolved there. The assize system thus served as the procedural bridge between centralized royal justice and local jury trial: pleadings and legal rulings were handled at Westminster, but the actual fact-finding occurred in the county where the dispute arose, before commissioners riding the circuit.
The term fuses two distinct but interrelated functions. The assize component refers to the commissioners' criminal jurisdiction — the power to try felonies and serious offenses in the county — as well as certain civil proceedings of ancient origin. The nisi prius component is a procedural device: an order directing that a cause be tried in Westminster "unless before" (nisi prius) the appointed day the judges of assize came to the county. In practice, the assize judges always arrived before the Westminster date, so the trial invariably happened locally. Over time "nisi prius" became shorthand for the trial of civil issues before a jury at the county sittings, as distinct from the purely legal argument conducted at Westminster.
---
Common Confusion
Researchers sometimes treat "assize" and "nisi prius" as synonyms for the same court or the same jurisdiction. They are not. Assizes encompassed criminal jurisdiction (commissions of oyer and terminer, and gaol delivery) as well as the ancient civil assizes of novel disseisin, mort d'ancestor, and darrein presentment. Nisi prius was specifically the civil jury-trial jurisdiction — issues sent down from Westminster for local determination. A single set of commissioners typically held both functions on the same circuit, which is why the courts are paired in the full name, but the legal basis for each was distinct and the records generated by each function differ.
---
Why It Matters in Research
This is a term of almost exclusively historical significance. The courts of assize were abolished in England and Wales by the Courts Act 1971, which replaced them (along with quarter sessions) with the unified Crown Court. Researchers working in English legal history before 1971 — and particularly before the procedural reforms of the mid-nineteenth century — will encounter these courts frequently and need to understand their dual nature to navigate records correctly.
Several research traps deserve attention. First, the records divide. Criminal business (oyer and terminer, gaol delivery) produced distinct record series from civil nisi prius business. Assize records at the National Archives are organized by circuit and by commission type; treating the entire archive as a single "assize court" will cause researchers to miss material. Second, the circuit organization shifted over centuries. The number and boundaries of circuits changed, as did which courts at Westminster fed into which assize commissions. A case that appears in King's Bench records as pending nisi prius may require tracing to a specific county's assize file for the trial record itself. Third, the abolition of the forms of action in the nineteenth century — particularly the Common Law Procedure Acts of 1852 and 1854 — significantly altered the procedural relationship between Westminster and the assizes, so sources from before and after reform describe a materially different system even when using the same vocabulary.
American researchers should note that several colonies and early states adopted nisi prius terminology for their own circuit-style trial sittings. The phrase appears in early American statutes and digests in a way that draws on English precedent but reflects local procedural adaptations. Do not assume that an American source using "nisi prius" describes an institution identical to the English original.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Black's Law Dictionary (2nd Ed.) describes these courts as composed of two or more commissioners sent by royal commission twice yearly on circuits round the kingdom, to try by local jury "the truth of such matters of fact as are there under dispute in the courts of Westminster Hall," citing Stephens's Commentaries and Blackstone's Commentaries. This definition captures the functional core accurately but is compressed in ways that may mislead.
What Black's does not make explicit is the layered commission structure — assize judges typically rode under multiple overlapping commissions simultaneously (of the peace, of oyer and terminer, of gaol delivery, and of assize and nisi prius), which gave them a range of jurisdiction that cannot be inferred from the nisi prius function alone. The definition also fixes the institution at a moment when it was already in mature, relatively stable form; it does not reflect the institution's medieval origins or its significant transformation under the Victorian procedural reforms.
Blackstone's treatment in the third volume of the Commentaries remains the most authoritative historical account of how the nisi prius mechanism worked in practice, and Stephens's Commentaries (cited in Black's) provides a useful early nineteenth-century update. Researchers seeking primary description of the assize system in its final Victorian form should consult those sources directly rather than relying solely on dictionary entries.
---
Jurisdictional Note
The institution is English and Welsh in origin and was abolished in England and Wales by the Courts Act 1971. Scotland maintained a separate and distinct circuit court system. American jurisdictions that adopted nisi prius terminology did so by statutory borrowing, and the resulting institutions varied considerably from state to state; the English model should not be assumed to govern American usage without local verification.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
See Law Mind Encyclopedia — English Court History; Common Law Procedure; Oyer and Terminer; Gaol Delivery.
---