CHARITABLE - The Law Mind Legal Dictionary

CHARITABLEAuthored

The Law Mind • 1108 words

Definition

In law, "charitable" describes the character, purpose, or status of an entity, gift, trust, or activity oriented toward public benefit rather than private gain. The term operates primarily as a modifier — charitable trust, charitable use, charitable institution, charitable contribution — and its meaning is determined by context.

1. Charitable use / charitable trust: A use or trust organized for purposes recognized at equity as sufficiently public in benefit to warrant special legal protection and enforcement. The category is broader than common speech implies. It encompasses not only relief of poverty but advancement of education, promotion of religion, support of science and art, and any other purpose beneficial to the community at large. English equity courts developed this understanding from the Statute of Elizabeth I (1601), and American courts inherited and extended it.

2. Charitable institution: An organization constituted to administer charitable purposes — whether public or private in funding — as distinct from a for-profit enterprise. Courts have used the term interchangeably with "eleemosynary institution" in older authorities.

3. Charitable contribution / donation: A gift to a qualifying organization or use that may carry legal consequences, including tax deductibility, immunity from certain legal claims, or special treatment under estate and trust law.

The through-line across contexts is public benefit without expectation of private return.

Common Language

Modern common usage (Wiktionary): Pertaining to charity; kind and generous; having the purpose or character of a charity.

Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): Full of love and goodwill; benevolent; liberal in judging others; liberal in benefactions to the poor.

The everyday sense of "charitable" tilts toward personal virtue — generosity, leniency, benevolence toward individuals in need. The legal sense is structural and categorical: it asks not whether a donor was kind-hearted but whether a purpose, organization, or gift meets criteria that make it legally "charitable." A billionaire's gift to a private club is generous; it is not charitable in law. A trust for the advancement of scientific research may feel impersonal but qualifies fully. Researchers should not let the moralistic connotations of the common word guide their reading of legal authorities.

Common Confusion

"Charitable" is sometimes used loosely as a synonym for "eleemosynary" (relating specifically to almsgiving) or "philanthropic" (relating to beneficence generally). In strict legal usage, eleemosynary is the narrower term, focused on relief of poverty, while charitable encompasses a far wider range of public-benefit purposes. The Statute of Elizabeth and its American successors deliberately expanded charitable purposes beyond poor relief, and courts have been explicit that the terms are not coextensive. Older authorities may use eleemosynary where modern drafting would say charitable.

Why It Matters in Research

The breadth problem is the central research trap. Researchers encountering "charitable" in historical sources must resist assuming it means only poverty relief or religious giving. Nineteenth-century equity courts — following Burrill's formulation closely — treated the category expansively, and a trust or institution that looks secular, educational, or scientific may be classified as charitable throughout the corpus.

Three distinct bodies of law use the term with somewhat different emphasis:

Trust and estate law uses "charitable" to distinguish purposes that courts will enforce even without an ascertainable private beneficiary — and that survive conditions (like the cy pres doctrine) that would kill a private trust. Researchers tracing charitable trust doctrine should track the cy pres and general charitable intent threads as companion concepts.

Tort law uses "charitable" as a historical immunity marker. The common law charitable immunity doctrine — shielding charitable institutions from negligence liability — has been substantially abrogated in most American jurisdictions, but historical sources treat it as robust. A researcher reading pre-1960 tort authorities about hospitals, schools, or churches will encounter this immunity frequently. Modern sources reflect its erosion.

Tax law uses "charitable" to define deductibility and exemption. The federal tax definition (IRC § 501(c)(3)) is specific, statutory, and not identical to the trust law definition. An organization may be charitable for trust purposes without qualifying under § 501(c)(3), and vice versa. Cross-referencing these frameworks without distinguishing them produces errors.

Jurisdictional variation in what qualifies as a "charitable purpose" is also real, particularly for edge cases like promotion of sport, political advocacy, or mutual benefit societies.

Historical Dictionary Support

The historical dictionaries converge on breadth as the defining feature. Burrill states explicitly that "charitable" in the expressions "charitable uses" and "charitable trusts" is "understood in a very large sense" — not limited to gifts for the poor, but extending to education, science, art, religion, and "any other useful and public purpose." This formulation echoes Stephen's Commentaries and reflects the Elizabethan statutory inheritance.

Black's 2nd edition is characteristically sparse — defining "charitable" circularly as "having the character or purpose of a charity" — but the sub-entry for "charitable institution" is useful: it links the term to "eleemosynary institution" while making clear that both public and private charities qualify. The case references in Black's (People v. Fitch; Balch v. Shaw; People v. New York Soc.; In re Vineland Historical Soc.) illustrate the diversity of entities courts treated as charitable institutions around the turn of the twentieth century.

Rapalje & Lawrence's excerpt in the source material does not address "charitable" directly — the quoted passage concerns "charges" in chancery pleading — and contributes nothing specific to this entry.

What the historical dictionaries collectively miss is the tax dimension, which is largely a twentieth-century development, and the immunity abrogation story in tort law. Researchers relying solely on these sources will have an accurate picture of trust and equity doctrine but an incomplete one for modern practice.

Jurisdictional Note

American states differ on what purposes qualify as charitable for trust enforcement purposes, with some jurisdictions following a narrow reading (substantially limited to traditional categories) and others adopting an open-ended public benefit test. The federal tax definition under § 501(c)(3) operates on its own axis and should not be imported into state trust law analysis without caution.

Encyclopedia Cross-Reference

Charitable Estate Planning — Charitable Remainder Trusts, Charitable Lead Trusts, and Donor-Advised Funds (The Law Mind Trusts, Estates & Probate Encyclopedia)
Defenses to Negligence — Immunities — Charitable and Familial (The Law Mind Torts & Personal Injury Encyclopedia)
Itemized Deductions — Charitable Contributions General (The Law Mind Tax Encyclopedia)

CHARITABLEmain

Rapalje & Lawrence • 1888

(197) 18. In chancery practice, charges are allegations in a bill of complaint intended either to substantiate the general statement of the plaintiff's case, or to avoid a defence which he anticipates that the defendant will set up. See BILL OF COMFLAINT, 6. 19. In an action for an account a person is said to be charged with sums which he admits or is proved to have received. When he brings in an account showing receipts and payments by him, he is said to charge himself with the receipts, and to discharge himself by the payments. See DISCHARGE; SURCHARGE. 10. In criminal law, a charge is an accusation made by a summons, warrant, information, indictment or the like. And the clerk gives the prisoner in charge to the jury by reading the indictment, and they are bound to proceed to deliver him until they are discharged. 11. To jury. The instructions given by the court, either to the grand jury before commencing their session, as to their duty, or to the petty jury, after the case on trial has been closed on both sides, are denominated, in either case, the "charge" of the court. See INSTRUCTIONS. CHARGE (in bankruptcy act). L. R. 9 Q. B. 286. (to a jury). 29 Wis. 125. (in statute requiring judge's charge to be written). 29 Wis. 125, 136. CHARGE AND ACCUSE, (before a grand jury or magistrate). 12 Cush. (Mass.) 90. (in an indictment under a statute). 2 Car. & P. 436. CHARGE, POWER TO, (includes power to sell). 8 Com. Dig. 859. CHARGE AND DISCHARGE.-The old mode of taking accounts in chancery. For an explanation of it, see Dan. Ch. Pr. 1173. CHARGÉ D'AFFAIRES. - A diplomatic agent, differing from an ambassador or minister in being accredited to the minister, not the sovereign, of the foreign State where he resides, and in representing a minister and not the sovereign of his own State. Man. L. of N. 106. custody, the nature of the accusation, and the name of the accuser in each case. It is under the care of the inspector on duty. This seems to be the same thing as the "blotter" used for the same purpose in this country. CHARGE TO ENTER HEIR.-In the Scotch law, a writ commanding a person to enter heir to his predecessor within forty days, otherwise an action to be raised against him as if he had entered.-Bouvier. CHARGEABLE, (in a statute). 44 Conn. 210; CHARGED, (in a plea). 1 Minn. 241. 11 East 381. (under statute, who are). 14 Johns. (N. Y.) 484.

CHARITABLEmain

Burrill's Law Dictionary • 1867

This word, in the expressions "charitable uses," "charitable trusts," is understood in a very large sense, comprising not only gifts for the benefit of the poor, but endowments for the advancement of learning, or institutions for the encouragement of science and art, and for any other useful and public purpose, as well as donations for pious or religious objects. 3 Steph. Com. 229. See 1 Id. 428, and note (b). 2 Chitt. Bl. Com. 273, 274, and notes. 2 Kent's Com. 285-288, and notes. 2 Story's Eq. Jur. §§ 1160-1164. Duke on Charit. Us. 105, 113, cited ibid. U. S. Digest, Charities and Charitable Uses.

CHARITABLEmain

Black's Law Dictionary (2nd Ed.) • 1910

Having the character or purpose of a charity, (q. v.) —~—Charitable institution. One administering a public or private charity; an eleemosynary institution. See People v. Fitch, 16 Misc. Rep. 464, 39 N. Y. Supe 926; Balch v. Shaw, 174 Mass. 144, 54 N. EB. 490; People v. New York Suc., ete., 162 N. Y. 429, 56 N. BE. 1004: In re Vineland Historical, etce., Soc.. 66 N. J. Eq. 291, 56 Atl. 1040.—Charitable uses or purposes. Originally those enumerated in the statute 43 Eliz. c. 4, and afterwards those which, by analogy. come within its spirit and purpose. In its present usage, the term is go broad as to include almost everything which tends to promote the physical or moral welfare of men, provided only the distribution of benefits is to be free and not a source of: profit. In respect to gifts and devises, and also in respect to freedom from taxation, charitable uses and purposes may include not only the relief of poverty by alms-giving and the relief of the indigent sick and of homeless persons by means 2 CHARITY of hospitals and asylums, but also religious instruction and the support of churches, the dissemination of knowledge by means of schools and colleges, libraries, scientific academies, and museums, the special care of children and of prisoners and released convicts, the benefit of handicraftsmen, the erection of public buildings, and reclamation of criminals in penitentiaries and reformatories. Hence the word “charitable” in this connection is not to be understood as strictly equivalent to ‘“eleemosynary,” but as the synonym of “‘benevolent” or ‘philanthropic.” Beckwith vy. Parish, 69 Ga. 569: Price v. Maxwell, 28 Pa. 23; Webster v. Sughrow, 69 N. H. 380, 45 Atl. 139, 48 L. R. A. 100; Jackson v. Phillips, 14 Allen (Mass.) 539; Harrington vy. Pier, 105 Wis. 485, 82 N. W. 345, 50 L. R. A. 307, 76 Am. St. art v. Easton, 74 red. 854, 21 C. C. A ; State v. Laramie County, 8 Wyo. 104, 55 Pac. 451; Gladding v. Church, 25 R. I. G28, 57 Atl. 860, 65 L, R. A. 225, 105 Am. St. Rep. 904.

CHARITABLEa.

Websters Unabridged Dictionary (1913) • 1913

Full of love and good will; benevolent; kind. Be thy intents wicked or charitable, . . . . . . I will speak to thee. Shak. Liberal in judging of others; disposed to look on the best side, and to avoid harsh judgment. Liberal in benefactions to the poor; giving freely; generous; beneficent. What charitable men afford to beggars. Shak. Of or pertaining to charity; springing from, or intended for, charity; relating to almsgiving; elemosynary; as, a charitable institution. Dictated by kindness; favorable; lenient. By a charitable construction it may be a sermon. L. Andrews.

charitableadj

Wiktionary (English) • 2026

Wiktionary contributors • CC BY-SA 4.0 • via Kaikki
Extracted and formatted for display by Law Mind. Source link opens the current Wiktionary page and its contributor history; it is not a frozen copy of this extract.

Pertaining to charity. | Kind, generous. | Having a purpose or character of a charity.

Explore the full Law Mind legal research platform.

Subscribe Encyclopedia Sign In