Definition
CHARGE carries distinct meanings depending on legal context. The four principal uses in Anglo-American law are:
1. Criminal accusation. A formal allegation by an authorized government body that a named person has committed a specific offense. The charge identifies the offense, the legal provision violated, and the essential facts underlying the accusation. It may take the form of an indictment, information, complaint, or citation depending on the jurisdiction and the severity of the offense.
2. Judicial instruction to a jury. The judge's address to the jury at the close of evidence, explaining the applicable law, the elements the fact-finder must assess, the burden of proof, and the permissible range of verdicts. Also called a jury charge or instructions.
3. An encumbrance on property. A lien, burden, or security interest imposed on real or personal property as security for a debt or obligation. The property is said to be "charged" with the obligation, meaning a creditor may look to that property for satisfaction. In equity, a charge may arise by express agreement or by operation of law.
4. A financial obligation or cost. A fee, expense, or assessment imposed on a person, account, or piece of property — as in carrying charges, service charges, or charges allocated between buyer and seller at a real estate closing.
A fifth, narrower use appears in agency and trust law: a principal or settlor may "charge" a fiduciary with responsibility for specific duties, assets, or accounts, meaning those items are formally committed to that person's care and accountability.
---
Common Language
Modern common usage (Wiktionary): A charge is widely understood as either a price or fee demanded for goods or services, a formal accusation against a person, an obligation or responsibility, or the act of rushing toward something.
Historical common usage (Webster's 1913): Webster's lists charge primarily as a burden or load, an accusation, a command or injunction, the price demanded, and a quantity of powder or shot for a firearm — reflecting the term's broad pre-legal currency.
The gap between common and legal meaning is not one of opposition but of precision. Ordinary speakers use "charge" loosely across all these senses without appreciating that each carries a distinct legal framework, procedural posture, and set of consequences. A criminal charge has constitutional dimensions entirely absent from a utility charge; a charge on property operates through equity and priority rules alien to the everyday understanding of "a fee." Researchers should be alert to which sense a source is using before importing analysis from one context into another.
---
Common Confusion
Three pairs of confusion arise with regularity:
CHARGE (criminal) vs. INDICTMENT vs. INFORMATION: These are not synonyms. A charge is the generic concept — the formal accusation. An indictment is a specific instrument by which a grand jury formally charges a defendant. An information is a charge brought directly by a prosecutor without grand jury action, available in many jurisdictions for misdemeanors and, in some, for felonies. All three are forms of charge, but they differ in their source, constitutional requirements, and procedural implications.
CHARGE (property) vs. LIEN vs. MORTGAGE: A charge on property is the broadest of these terms. A lien is a species of charge — a specific legal claim against identified property. A mortgage is a specific instrument creating a charge. In historical equity practice, charges could arise informally and without the formal execution required for a mortgage. Modern American practice has largely absorbed equitable charges into the lien framework, but older English and some American cases preserve the distinction.
CHARGE (jury) vs. INSTRUCTION: These terms are functionally synonymous in modern American practice, but older sources and some jurisdictions reserve "charge" for the judge's complete address to the jury and "instruction" for individual numbered directives within it. In historical materials, "charge" more consistently meant the whole address.
---
Recognized Forms
/SUBTYPES
Criminal context:
— General charge: An accusation not broken into specific counts.
— Special charge: An accusation directed at a particular transaction or a particular legal theory within a broader indictment.
— Multiple counts: A single charging instrument may contain several discrete charges, each independently prosecutable.
Jury instruction context:
— General charge: The overall address covering all elements of law applicable to the case.
— Special charge: A specific instruction requested by a party on a particular point of law, which the judge may give or refuse.
Property context:
— Fixed charge: A charge attached to specific, identified property.
— Floating charge: A charge over a class of assets (common in English commercial law and some American secured transactions) that attaches to whatever assets fall within the class at the time of crystallization. Highly significant in corporate insolvency analysis.
— Charging order: A court order that charges a debtor's interest in a partnership or LLC with the obligation to satisfy a judgment, without transferring ownership of the underlying interest.
---
Why It Matters in Research
The single greatest research trap with CHARGE is context collapse — assuming that analysis, doctrine, or procedure from one sense of the word governs another. A researcher following a citation about "charges" in an equity treatise may be reading about property encumbrances, not criminal accusations.
In criminal law research, the charge defines the universe of the prosecution. Constitutional protections — notice, double jeopardy, the right to a speedy trial — attach to the charge as framed. What is and is not charged controls what the jury may consider and what the defendant may be convicted of. Changes to a charge mid-proceedings (amendment, superseding indictment, variance) are procedurally significant and case-dispositive. Researchers working in this area should move directly to the Sixth Amendment encyclopedia entry noted above.
In jury instruction research, the "charge" is both an event (the judge's address) and a document (the written instructions). Appellate review of charges is highly technical: error in a charge may be reversible or harmless depending on whether it was objected to below, whether it misstated the law, and whether it was likely to have misled the jury. Historical reporters often print the charge verbatim, making them a valuable primary source for how courts understood the law at a given moment.
In property and secured transactions research, the floating charge is a concept borrowed heavily from English law and requires care when applied to American materials. American LLC and partnership law has developed the charging order as its primary mechanism for creditors of individual members or partners — a creature that operates like a charge on the economic interest without giving the creditor management rights. This distinction is commercially significant and is addressed in detail in the LLC encyclopedia entry noted above.
In real estate closing research, "charges" typically refers to the line items allocated between buyer and seller at settlement — taxes, assessments, HOA dues, utility deposits. These are financial obligations running with property ownership and are prorated as of the closing date. This usage overlaps with the property-encumbrance sense but is operationally distinct: proration charges are transactional accounting, not security interests.
Older American and English sources use "charge" in the property sense very broadly, sometimes where modern practice would use "lien," "encumbrance," or "security interest." Translating between historical and modern terminology requires checking whether the source was operating in equity or at law, and whether the relevant jurisdiction has since codified what was once an equitable charge into a statutory lien framework.
---
Historical Dictionary Support
Rapalje & Lawrence give CHARGE substantial treatment, reflecting its importance across multiple fields of practice in late nineteenth-century American and English law. They present the property-encumbrance meaning with particular care, distinguishing a charge from a lien by noting that a charge may exist in equity over property not subject to a common-law lien, and may arise by implication or agreement without the formalities required for a legal mortgage. This equity-based flexibility was a working feature of practice, not a theoretical nicety.
On the criminal side, Rapalje & Lawrence treat the formal accusation sense as primary, consistent with the usage of their era, and note the connection to the grand jury process. The jury instruction sense is acknowledged but receives less development — reflecting that in 1883 the elaborate modern law of jury instructions had not yet fully crystallized into a distinct body of appellate doctrine.
The financial obligation sense (fees, assessments, costs) appears in Rapalje & Lawrence but without systematic treatment, which is consistent with the pattern that historical dictionaries underserve the transactional and commercial valences of terms that later became important in real estate closings and corporate finance.
What the historical sources miss almost entirely is the floating charge as a distinct concept and the charging order as a mechanism for judgment creditors against business-entity interests. Both are products of later doctrinal development — the floating charge emerging from English corporate practice in the late nineteenth century and expanding through the twentieth, and the charging order becoming a major focus of American LLC law from the 1990s forward. Researchers working on either concept should not expect historical dictionaries to provide reliable modern guidance.
---
Jurisdictional Note
The criminal charge process varies significantly across American jurisdictions. Federal practice and roughly half the states require grand jury indictment for serious felonies; others permit the prosecutor's information as a substitute. In England and Wales, the modern "charge" in criminal procedure is a distinct formal step by police or the Crown Prosecution Service, with its own procedural rules that diverge from American practice. The floating charge, as a formal legal concept, is primarily English and Commonwealth; American secured transactions law under Article 9 of the UCC captures similar commercial needs through different mechanisms.
---
Encyclopedia Cross-Reference
The Law Mind Criminal Law Encyclopedia: "Sixth Amendment — Right to Be Informed of Charges" (criminal charge, notice requirements, constitutional framework)
The Law Mind Business Organizations & Corporate Law Encyclopedia: "LLCs — Transferability of LLC Membership Interests and Charging Orders" (charging order as creditor remedy against LLC membership interests)
The Law Mind Real Estate Transactions & Construction Encyclopedia: "Prorations — Taxes, Insurance, Rents, HOA Assessments, and Utility Charges" (charges as closing line items and allocation mechanics)
---